Dear Parishioners,
As the events of last week subside a little, we would like to give you an update on the present situation concerning the future of Fr Bob as the parish priest of Sts Peter & Paul, South Melbourne.
As you may recall, the Archbishop requested that Fr Bob tender his resignation by no later than 17 September, 2009. Fr Bob will reply to that request on the due date. We do not profess to speak for Fr Bob, but he has indicated publicly that his response will be to not offer his resignation.
In the meantime, your Parish Council wrote to the Archbishop informing His Grace of the support of the parish community for Fr Bob to remain as our Parish Priest, and requesting him to engage in dialogue with the Parish Council before he made any determination as to the position of Parish Priest. The Archbishop has replied saying that he intends to wait until such time as he receives a reply from Fr Bob before having any further discussion with the Parish Council.
We continue to emphasise that this situation is different from the recent events of St Mary’s, South Brisbane and that the response of the parish will be different. We are fundamentally wishing to see a resolution within the parameters that Church doctrine and Canon law provide, and the parish – including Fr Bob – remains committed to the orthodoxy of the Catholic Church (even if we veer towards the unconventional some of the time).
For those that were not able to make it to mass last Sunday at 10am, the parish community (swollen in numbers by the influx of a large number of supporters - not to mention media) celebrated Fr Bob’s 75th birthday in style. Frank O’Connor delivered the statement set out below on behalf of the Parish Council.
There continues to be a great deal of goodwill and support towards Fr Bob.
There is nothing more to report than that at this point in time. We will, of course, continue to keep you informed as matters progress. Your prayers for the Archbishop, Fr Bob, the parish community and the people of South Melbourne and surrounding districts would be greatly appreciated.
Paul Wappett
Parish Communications
Statement by Frank O’Connor to 10am Mass – Sunday 13th September 2009
Thanks for being here. And the great turnout is indicative of the esteem in which Bob is held, not just by this Parish for the last 36 years but also by the much wider community, and certainly inclusive of people of all religions and beliefs and of all strata in society. And today is really meant to be the celebration of Fr Bob’s 75th birthday so we intend doing that celebration at the end of this liturgical celebration.
On the other very public matter, let me reassure all of you that there is plenty of work going on in relation to the Archbishop’s proposal to force Bob to resign. And let me be very clear on this. Although the theory is that when Bob turns 75 he is required to submit his offer to resign and then the Archbishop will consider it, there is plenty of evidence in both Archbishop’s letter and other communication and in his discussion with Bob that he has already made up his mind. We would not expect that to be so and hence our request to meet with him to discuss these issues.
And now we have the new issue in today’s media which suggests that the Archbishop wants Fr Bob out not because he’s turning 75 but because he doesn’t like how he spends money on the poor.
Fr Bob has been accused of selling off assets to fund his charitable works. Now let’s be very clear about asset sales. Only the Archbishop can approve the sale of any Parish assets hence any sales that have occurred over the past 30 years have been done at the Parish’s instigation but with the full knowledge and ultimate approval of the Archdiocese.
And why would the Parish want to sell such assets? Clearly they were excess to requirements and the Parish needed to generate cash, not just for its charitable works but also for normal day to day running. The reality is, and the Archdiocese knows this and parishioners have been regularly informed of it, the revenue we receive leaves us about $120,000 per year short of essential expenditure. And let’s not forget that the Parish spent more than $800,000 on restoring this historic church and a further $200,000 on the heritage Parish House, from our own resources and with no external funding or support. All this shows that Fr Bob has managed things extraordinarily well given the circumstances.
Bob himself is of course running a magnificent PR campaign in relation to the Archbishop’s desire to see him resign, just as over the years he has used the media to promote and fight for the cause of the disadvantaged and the dispossessed, irrespective of whether people were the deserving or undeserving poor – judging people to decide whether to help them has never been in Bob’s approach.
Besides Bob’s PR work, there are many others including the Parish Council here in South Melbourne and local community, political, media and industry figures who have or will be writing to the Archbishop urging him to leave Bob here in South Melbourne as Parish Priest. That’s so he can continue his magnificent work with those who need his support and equally important so that he can continue to inspire others with his ability to preach the message of the Gospel as it needs to be applied to life and living in this day and age.
But let me though give you a particular piece of advice. This Parish of Sts Peter & Paul South Melbourne is not another South Brisbane. Fr Bob is orthodox, even if a little unconventional at times, and hence this Parish has been moulded that way. We have no plans to man the barricades or storm the Cathedral. We believe that the very broad support that Bob has, as evidenced by today’s turnout, together with the fact that at 75 years of age he is still fit and well and sharp of mind, ought to be enough evidence for the Archbishop to make the decision that Bob can continue here as Parish Priest.
However, it may be that more will be needed to convince the Archbishop. In that case we may well continue to call on your support. So we ask you to keep an eye on the Parish website or follow Fr Bob’s blog. So to quote Fr Bob “No more us and them, just we”, let’s reassure Bob that WE want him to continue as Parish Priest of this Parish and WE need to convince Archbishop Hart that this is the right outcome.